Wilco – Yankee Hotel Foxtrot

Chris Ryan week concludes with a selection from circa 2002 (although it was available online for free before that).  Based out of the windy city….Chicago, IL

Wilco – Yankee Hotel Foxtrot

Listen to it here:  http://grooveshark.com/#!/playlist/Wilco+Yankee+Foxtrot/69163935

Read about the album here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yankee_Hotel_Foxtrot
One year ago:  We listened to J Dilla’s “Donuts”.

Fun Facts:  The album was named after a series of letters in the phonetic alphabet that Tweedy had heard on the Irdial box set The Conet Project: Recordings of Shortwave Numbers Stations. On the fourth track of the album  Phonetic Alphabet – Nato (help·info), a woman repeats the words “Yankee Hotel Foxtrot” numerous times; a clip from this track was placed in the Yankee Hotel Foxtrot song “Poor Places”. Irdial sued Wilco for copyright infringement, and a settlement was reached out of court.[7]

Josh:

Wilco – Yankee Hotel Foxtrot: 5 stars

Precon: One of my favorite albums. Like many people, it’s the one that introduced me to Wilco, although I think I’d heard of them before but never paid attention. I didn’t even pay attention after this blew up until I heard the backstory of the album getting dropped by a major label, gaining huge internet buzz, then getting picked up by a subsidiary of the same label for a higher price. I remember buying this along with The Streets’ A Grand Don’t Come For Free and Interpol’s Turn on the Bright Lights right before a trip to Disney in 2005, forever linking the three. It’s funny, the circumstances that create such indelible marks on your subconscious, like sitting in the terminal at Bradley in a hazy 5am fugue, a little nervous, a little hungry, gooesbumps because you’re dressed for 90 but it’s 45, with your Sony Discman on its farewell tour etching three albums into the wax cylinder of your brain. Of the three, Wilco obviously came out on top, with the Streets not too far behind, but even something like the Interpol album, which I don’t listen to much anymore, can evoke such powerful feelings if I were to just put it on for 30 seconds, and it’s all because of those subconscious bonds. This is why we have a record club.

Favorite Track: I can never decide between Jesus Etc and I’m the Man Who Loves You.
Least Favorite: I’ll have to go with Reservations for 3 minutes of noises, though they’re not bad noises.

My first thought about this album was that “I Am Trying to Break Your Heart” had annoying lyrics. I used to think lines like “I assassin down the avenue” were painfully artsy and smacked of trying too hard. Doesn’t really bother me at all anymore, but I guess, being fresh out of college back then, I was quicker to judge. I similarly turned my nose up at the xylophone (vibraphone?) in “Kamera” thinking it was too cute, but now I think it’s fine. Not sure if I’ve become less snobby or more boorish.

One part of “I Am Trying to Break Your Heart” I always found interesting was the “I’m the man who loves you” bit at the end. I wonder which song came first. Was this a reference to the other song or was it the seed?

“Radio Cure” is just a little too protracted and depressed for me. Yeah, that’s what it’s about, but I still wish they reworked it a little. So the whole thing is disinterested for the first half, then we get teased like it’s about to pick up, then it stalls, then it finally delivers for about 45 seconds near the end before another 30 seconds of depression. They could have got that same payoff without so much stalling, and it wouldn’t have disrupted the flow of the album as much.

As I’ve stated before, this album has the greatest tracks 4-9 ever. “War on War” and “Pot Kettle Black” the staunch bookends, “Jesus Etc” one of the stars of the whole album with the violin and that chorus, close to a perfect song, “Ashes of American Flags” maybe the worst of the bunch but still good, “Heavy Metal Drummer” probably the most accessible song on the album, and of course “I’m the Man Who Loves You,” the other standout with its style juxtapositions and creative phrasing. It’s a good run.

An incredible album with added significance for me that puts it in the all timer category. I love it.

Marissa:

Wilco-Yankee Hotel Foxtrot

Preconceived Notions: I feel like this album was one of those things that really started this whole notion of a more concentrated effort of listening for me.  A couple of years ago when I revealed that I had not, in fact, heard this album, Chris Ryan pretty much made sure I listened to it then and there.  There were things I liked, things that didn’t grab me, but I can’t say that I remember anything about the album, specifically from that listen.  I’m curious to see if it still fades into the background after all of these other albums, or if the purported greatness of this album from numerous online and tactile publications, finally smacks me full in the face this time.  Maybe it’s a case where with a better listener, a better album emerges, I don’t know.  I do have the sense that, for many, this album is like hipster Mecca on their cd racks or, more likely, vinyl collections and that I’ve been meaning to watch the documentary on Netflix for at least three weeks now.

As Listening:
Jesus, Etc.- I lied, I remember this song and still really like it.  I’m not sure that two weeks ago, if I had heard it randomly played I would have remembered that it was Wilco, but I definitely remember hearing this song from the first time.

After Listening:  I think the problem that I have with this album is the monotony of it.  Every song seems to have pretty much the same pacing and a pretty similar feel and Tweedy’s voice, while nice, is just that, nice.  The songs are nice too.  I actually liked that there was a live version thrown in on the album because it changed things up, gave it a different feel and it might be that Wilco is just a live band.  Maybe all of the love built up for these guys is from seeing them live but I just didn’t feel like any of that passion translated into the recordings.  Yankee Hotel Foxtrot hits a high plateau, but a plateau nonetheless.  It’s polished, with great production, but with the exception of 3 tracks, I felt like it was all just washing over me, it wasn’t unpleasant per se, but more like a lukewarm shower that leans towards the cold side, where you think it’ll be ok and then four minutes in, you just want it over with.

Overall: 3.6

Favorite tracks: Jesus, Etc/Poor Places/Kamera
Least Favorite: Everything else was adequate, nothing terrible.

Mike:

Preconceived Notions:  I gave Wilco a chance on some stuff during the golden days of pre-record club, when CGR sat diagonally across from me – and when we would take lunch with brews, before it was all ended by a beast from the northern country. Anywho, Wilco might have been one of the very 1st bands we went back and forth on…and unfortunately I could never get into the samples Chris sent my way.  I seem to recall them having a very “Grateful Dead” vibe to them, and I loathe the Dead.  I was certain they’d pop up during RC season 1, but I guess all things in time.

After Listening:  There are definite moments of “The Dead” influence here, mixed in among some light heroin vibes, pop, and vague indie rock references.  There’s some decent guitar work on this record, it isn’t anything brand new – but you have to appreciate the solid musicianship in the cleverly muted sections  And they do mix in their various influences with a reasonable amount of control and a good instrumental palate from lap steel guitar, to horns, to vibraphone. The album sort of struggles when they add energy to the mix, they don’t ever verge over the cliff into complete cacophony- in fact they wind up in the complete generic opposite direction.  And so the album presents me with sort of a conflict – Wilco is better in their mellow jam moments than their rock moments, and yet I’m not a big fan of jam music.  Vocally I can’t really identify with the voice except for when it veers close to Jerry Garica territory –and even then it’s not an instant irritant unless the music behind it makes it so.

Favorite Tracks: Kamera –  There’s a very subtle aggressive rhythm going on beneath the vocals here.  Short, competent guitar lines and what I believe to be glockenspiel accents – this gives it sort of a pots and pans type of retro rock feel.
Jesus Etc – There’s some very nice instrumentation here, from a violin in an almost country western twang to a good dose of lap steel guitar. The melody lines and their corresponding vocal lines bring to mind folk and country nearly simultaneously…and the 2nd half of the song has some excellent pizzicato violin work.

Least Favorite Tracks: War on War – just a folk song updated for our generation. But not really updated in any way that makes it a distinct sounding piece of music.  You listen and you know it was recorded in the modern era thanks to some weird & brief synth effects, but there’s virtually nothing new about the chord patterns or any of the arrangements. This one has the most of the Grateful Dead influence on the album.
“Heavy Metal Drummer” –  And the title had me so looking forward to this one too…oh well. It’s a pop song – bland musically, and only with a line or two vocally to mark the time.

Overall 2.93 Wilco seems to be one of the 00’s real darling and influential acts, and even after listening to now an album’s worth of their material I can’t do more than guess as to why that would be.   Maybe part of it is that in comparison to some of their peers Wilco actually does deserve some nominal credit for tinkering with instrumentation, and no doubt their fame in part has to rest on their anti-corporate release of this very album – I mean if anything screams “indie”, releasing an album free online because of contract and ownership feuds with record companies more than fits that bill.  And those things are all well and good, but I can’t anoint them anything based on purely the music they produce.  It all winds up just sort of ok, surprisingly to me better in its mellow moments – most of this album anyway hits the average or worse category when they “rock” things up.  A record I’m glad to have experienced for the experience, but not one worth putting into rotation.

Ali:

Wilco – Yankee Hotel Foxtrot
Preconceptions:
I HAVE heard of Wilco before, but I’m pretty sure it was listening to one of them getting interviewed by Chris Hardwick for the Nerdist podcast. It’s probably uncool of me to admit that I haven’t heard any of their music (that I know of).

Mood:
Meh

After Listening:
Actually I wouldn’t mind listening to more of this group. It pulled me in with the first song and feels like a jam session that they recorded and then listened to and tweaked slightly before doing a studio recording. They make use of noises and dischord (ESPECIALLY on the piano in the first one) and that draws me in.
Sadly, I think when this came out I would have REALLY enjoyed a lot of the songs more, but it feels like I’ve heard a lot of them before and I don’t think I’ve actually heard them before.

Favorite track/tracks:
I am trying to break your heart
Jesus, etc.

Least favorite track/tracks:
I’m the man who loves you – (Honestly, I’m not a fan of reverb if it’s used as its own instrument.)
Poor places

Overall (1-5 stars):  3

admin (196 Posts)

Record Club began in the cold, dank, snowmageddon scene that was New England of January 2011. We’re probably no different than you. We all work in cubicles, some in smaller, less private cubicles than others; that just means we have to be even sneakier about how we listen to our music. But we have to listen to our music, mostly as a way of saving our own personal sanity. Sometimes our opinions lead us to debates that may or may not be published in their entirety on this site, but I can promise you’ll at least get a glimpse of the way our minds work. The main goal is to find new music we like or find old music that we didn’t know we liked. Sometimes we succeed, sometimes it’s a total and complete disaster. After our ears have rejoiced or stopped bleeding we try something else. This is our pattern, every Tuesday and Thursday. Sometimes, when the club isn’t officially in session, just to keep everyone on their toes, we throw in a theme day. We’re beginning to run low on our original list, so please, if you have albums that you’d like us to review or themes that you’d like to see our playlist of, feel free to contribute. After all, we’re all in this together once we punch the time clock. So if you’re busy (or just plain bored) lurking in your cubicle as you read this join in. After all, life wasn’t meant to be lived staring at a computer screen. I guarantee you, it’s at least more fun when you plug the headphones in.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *